Vietnam: CSW joins calls for investigation into suspicious death in custody

In an open letter to the Vietnamese Minister of Public Security, over 30 civil society organisations, including Christian Solidarity Worldwide (CSW), have called for anindependent, impartial and effective investigation into the suspicious circumstances surrounding the death of Hoa Hao Buddhist Nguyen Huu Tan.

Mr Tan died within ten hours of being taken into custody at a police detention facility in Vinh Long Province on 3 May 2017. The authorities claim that Mr Tan committed suicide by cutting his own throat with a letter opener. However, his injuries, including bruising to the forehead, suggest that he may have been tortured in police custody, and other explanations and materials provided by the police as evidence of suicide are inconsistent and contradictory. Family members who have requested an investigation into his death have been harassed and threatened with arrest.

The joint letter calls for an investigation into Mr Tan’s death and for the prosecution of any individuals against whom there is sufficient, prima facie admissible evidence of unlawful involvement in the death. The authorities are also urged to cease their intimidation and harassment of Mr Tan’s family immediately.

Nguyen Huu Tan was a Hoa Hao Buddhist and the son of Buddhist monk Nguyen Huu Quang. Although Hoa Hao Buddhism is recognised by the Vietnamese government, many Hoa Hao Buddhists refuse to belong to the state-sponsored Hoa Hao Administrative Council, which was established by the Vietnam Fatherland Front, a body under the leadership of the Communist Party of Vietnam. CSW’s research suggests that independent Hoa Hao Buddhist groups and their members suffer ongoing harassment by the authorities, including confiscation of land used for religious worship, intrusive surveillance and disruption of religious activities.

Mr Tan was detained under Article 88 of Vietnam’s Penal Code, an article with broad and undefined prohibitions against conducting anti-state propaganda, which is often levelled at petitioners and activists. His family have been the subject of ongoing harassment and surveillance in connection with their affiliation with an independent Hoa Hao Buddhist religious group. Mr Tan’s father had previously petitioned the government for the return of temple land confiscated and sold by the authorities.

Christian Solidarity Worldwide’s Chief Executive Mervyn Thomas said, “This is a shocking and tragic case which has had a devastating impact on Mr Tan’s family and community. The explanation given by the police is inconsistent with the circumstances of Mr Tan’s death. It is believed that Mr Tan was detained in connection with his affiliation with an independent Hoa Hao Buddhist religious group, in violation of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which Vietnam has ratified. His death is the tragic outcome of his arbitrary and unlawful detention. The subsequent harassment of his family members is also unjustifiable, unlawful and inhumane. We call on the authorities to launch an independent, impartial and effective investigation, to cease harassment of the victim’s family, and to protect the right to freedom of religion or belief for all.”

Notes to Editors:

1. Click here to read CSW’s report into Nguyen Huu Tan’s death. Warning: this report contains graphic content.