CSW - everyone free to believe


Religious minority families at imminent risk of being expelled

13 Nov 2020

Community leaders in a village in Hidalgo state are threatening to expel two Protestant families if they do not fully pay a fine levied against them because of their religious beliefs.

The two families belong to a group of Protestant families in La Mesa Limantitla, located in the Huasteca region of Hidalgo, who were pressured to sign an agreement renouncing their faith in January 2019. While eight families signed the agreement, Nemesio Cruz Hernández, Eligio Santiago Hernández and their wives, Maria Francisca Martínez Hernández and Angelina Martínez Hernández, refused to do so. As a result, their access to water, drainage, government benefit programs and the community mill were blocked for over a year.

The families were forced to sign an illegal agreement on 15 January 2020 in which they renounced their right to hold religious services in order to have their access to water and other essential services reinstated. The state authorities paid part of a fine of $57,700 Mexican pesos (approximately £2136) that was levied against each family as part of the agreement. However, after several follow-up meetings, including on 22 August and most recently on 7 November, the families have been told that they face being cut off from essential services again or expelled from the community as they cannot afford to pay the rest of the fine.

Nemesio Cruz Hernández told CSW: “[The community leaders] have called a meeting to decide on our future this Saturday, 14 November. We are afraid that not only will they suspend our access to services but that we will be expelled from the community.”

The families had previously been threatened with forced displacement by community leaders in July 2019 if they did not make financial contributions to local Roman Catholic festivals and participate in other activities which conflicted with their religious beliefs.

Violations of freedom of religion or belief (FoRB) are common in the Huasteca region of Hidalgo, which has a large indigenous population. Examples include the denial of access to essential services such as water and electricity for religious minorities, blocking religious minority children from attending school, arbitrary detention and forced displacement.

Mexican law gives indigenous communities the right to protect their culture and maintain traditional governing structures as long as fundamental human rights protected by the Mexican constitution, including FoRB, are respected. However, a lack of understanding of these provisions and government inaction leads to high incidences of rights violations.

CSW’s CEO Scot Bower said: “We are deeply troubled by the escalating threats against Nemesio Cruz Hernández, Eligio Santiago Hernández and their families in La Mesa Limantitla, and what could happen to them if the state government does not take swift action to ensure that their right to freedom of religion or belief is upheld. We call on local authorities in La Mesa Limantitla to cease harassment of these families and to allow them to practise their religion free from hindrance or illegal conditions. We also call on Hidalgo State Governor Omar Fayad Meneses to address the injustices against these families without delay, and to ensure that officials in his administration uphold rule of law. Both federal and state governments in Mexico must uphold the right to freedom of religion or belief and ensure just outcomes for all religious minority communities experiencing violations on account of their religious beliefs.”



Sign up for updates on the work of CSW

* mandatory fields

By signing up you will receive news about CSW's work and how you can support it. You can unsubscribe at any time.

#2 CSW manifesto

We believe no one should suffer discrimination, harassment or persecution because of their beliefs